A basic liberalism (in the real not derogatory sense of the term) would mean allowing women to have a variety of sexual experiences without labeling them as victims and not treating young men as “predators” or calling for punitive action by the state because of what happened in the bedroom. The Paglia quote is good — sexual freedom means freedom for a variety of experience without training wheels or safeguards. Though, I would say that there should be no reason a young woman has to feel ashamed or degraded by a “taboo” sexual experience, except that the social taboo exists. A truly free sexuality would allow for a more open-ended relationship to sexual experience, not resolving ambiguity into “good” and “bad,” even less “dignity” or “shame,” so long as the experience was entered upon freely. On this point I must disagree with Christina, though I sympathize with her experience.
Good on Nikos and Christina for bravely voicing their thoughts on a difficult topic. Do not mind the people freaking out. Responding to speech with anger, fear or violence is always right-wing and reactionary — indicative of an authoritarian personality. Sundial should stand by its authors! It is never wrong to stand up for what is right against the mob — and to defend our ability to hear a variety of perspectives, however potentially offensive or strange to us, is indeed righteous.
As a longtime card-carrying , 90s-women’s-college feminist I support having this conversation. Nothing should be off limits, and Paglia’s perspective has long been debated in the feminist canon. Please don’t freak out about an article in a free speech publication, off all things, now.✌️
That it is now considered 'brave' to express an opinion that was considered common sense by every generation up until the present one, is for me the only issue of interest to me in all this. How did this happen? And what lessons can be drawn? The obvious one is we are seeing the consequence of raising a generation of children with few siblings and completely protected from 'bullying', free unsupervised play, and rough-housing.
Well yeah, they ARE politicians (that Trump is very much not is what made him refreshing for a while) .. but at what point does fecklessness segue into senility and puppetry. Their job is to breathe, provide the illusion of grownups in charge, while someone else moves their fingers to sign a page .. from McConnell to Biden .. to Diane Feinstein. Pelosi may be the only one, for better and worse, who kept her wits and spoke for herself to the very end. But yes, you have a point.
The Paglia quote is pretty bad. No, this not true: if a “young man says to you, ‘Would you like to go up to my room?’ I’m sorry, ok, you are consenting to sex.”
If you’re a young man who invited a girl up to your room and she agrees that doesn’t mean she wants to have sex with you. She might! But the mere agreement to go upstairs doesn’t mean she’s consenting to sex.
Congrats, you just infantilized women. If a woman can't figure out that "go up to my room" in a frat house is a euphemism for sex, then she has the mental maturity of a 5-year old.
It's a pretty reasonable assumption that "would you like to go up to my room?" means that the frat guy wants to have sex with her. It does not follow, morally or legally, that her going up to said room means that she has consented to sex with him.
In Paglia's day that was the shared understanding, because the man was usually enough of a gentleman to not just ask for sex very directly, that's her point, unless you can clearly communicate "yes sex", "no sex", you end up in the gray zone of dubious consent where one side assumes something and the other side assumes something else,
The statement is that an agreement to go up to someone's room is "consenting to sex". Not that there's a gray zone, or assumptions, that the woman is "consenting to sex". Which is untrue.
Again, depends on the era and the culture. Camille lived in a culture where “go up to a man’s room” meant having sex with him, without having to spell that out. I don’t know if we still have that culture anywhere, which is why I said: “hey if some guy invites you up to his room you’d better make sure it’s not for anything you don’t want” (it’s why i eventually broke up with my boyfriend, he kept wanting to fornicate with me and I didn’t want to fornicate with anybody)
Paglia’s phrasing is a rhetorical device. She’s not literally consenting to sex. This scene from a now-ancient movie beautifully illustrates … something. Not sure how to describe it but it seems directly relevant to the larger dialog, both in the Sundial piece and these comments. It starts slow, but be patient: it’s only 2 minutes long.
You're right, it's not a rhetorical device. I should have said, "she's describing a truth about how men and women naturally relate to one another, another aspect of which is depicted amusingly in the movie Tootsie." Or something like that.
I had a similar response and was ready to click "reply" when I remembered the Bolsheviks used to talk about "right" and "left." That poster seems to be pretty deep into academic Marxism.
Claude summarized it as below, but the sequence is reversed. Stalin got rid of Trotsky and then proceeded to implement the Left's program ... which he blamed on the Right, who he then liquidated. (Or something like that.)
"In Bolshevik usage, “right” meant gradualism (NEP, concessions to the peasantry), while “left” meant rapid industrialization, world revolution, and often more coercion.
"Bukharin’s Right Opposition opposed forced collectivization. The Left Communists of 1918 were the ones who wanted revolutionary war.
"Trotsky, a “left” figure, advocated militarizing labor and crushed Kronstadt.
"Stalin posed as a centrist, defeated the Left, then the Right, and ended up the most authoritarian of all."
It's not indicative of "authoritarianism" or "censorship" when people are called out for making a genuinely thoughtless and uncritical argument devoid of any self-awareness. It's not a freedom to be lazy and bad with your reasoning, or just say whatever you want and expect everybody to defend it on the basis of unilateral "free speech."Freedom of speech means freedom to shit on people who are just generally bad at speaking -- per your definition of freedom, right? ;)
It's one thing for an article to evoke negative response to the substance of the article. The author is free to speak - and the readers are free to speak in disagreement - absolutely. But what is troubling to me as a 53 year old woman, feminist, leftist, attorney - is when people go beyond panning an article - or vigorously disputing its substance - to wanting/ demanding/ feeling entitled to "consequences" for the author, and even the publisher! This punitive, reactionary, proverbial *pearl clutching* zeitgeist - is anathema to the "marketplace of ideas," a cornerstone of American political philosophy. True- the First Amendment only applies to government actors. But the philosophical tenet on which it rests is broadly applicable, and Americans typically agree in the abstract that we benefit as a society from a free marketplace of ideas. So why the knee jerk inclination to get heads on stakes.
To quote John Stuart Mill for the Columbia core curriculum crowd - "[T]he peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error."
So yes, attack the SPEECH, not the SPEAKER (and certainly not the Publisher). Some of the article was lazy and/or insensitive. But the truth is that the issues are not black and white in that case. My friend from law school, Tiffany Blacknell (@lwyrchc) is covering this case in an unbiased way, going over the charges against each of the 7 guys - because they should NOT be lumped all together. At least one of the guys as I understand is not accused of doing anything more than walking into the room, doing ketamine, and leaving. It is only fair to consider the allegations against the guys separately. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DecbfxzvkNF/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
I agree with lawditory (my fellow leftist!) that the pearl clutching response has been bad for thinking.
You are at liberty to respond to speech in an authoritarian manner, yes! Of course you have that right. And society has the freedom to descend into utter thoughtlessness and aggression. But the task of critical thought — and may I say of the Left — is to reflect openly on the variety of forms the ideology of our time takes. Freedom must be realized socially, it is not determined merely by law.
The many thoughtless and insubstantial condemnations of this article and its authors, including death threats, are about shutting down any discussion. They are the result of an hysterical sex panic. Most people decided the words were “dangerous” before even reading it. Can words really be dangerous? If this article is “dangerous” then what about articles commenting on war or revolution, events which actually involve the loss of life of hundreds, thousands or even millions of people? Clearly the response is overblown. People are so intolerant of the variety of sexual experience that they cannot stand to even read what these authors have written.
Yes, I was attacking the speech, not the speaker. We are on the same page there. I'm against moralizing witch-hunts that are unfounded on genuine critique. At the same time, I do think that I did openly reflect on this matter; what I say in response to the freedom of speech *is* precisely my stance. At the same moment you condemn people for launching insubstantial condemnations of this article and its authors, you extrapolate my critique to a moralizing one; the same moment you push for genuine critique, you misrecognize my genuine critique as something else, something secondary. That is not the case. The fact of the matter is that there are rhetorics that are dangerous, and the response to them should neither be libertarian nor authoritarian: it is not that the 'left' and the 'right' exist on a spectrum, and that they are quantitatively equivalent with the same weight, just inverted. Their relationship is much more complicated than a horizontal one; there is as some might say a power relation between what we consider to be the sides. That said, yes, some rhetorics are innately tied to the exercise of power in certain functions, but that is no basis to make any moral (generalized) judgments -- that is just how it works.
At the same time, all this constitutional-liberal, idealist, high-brow and removed intellectual onanism is not productive to attaining real material justice. I've yet to hear a case as to why this article is genuinely assisting the discourse -- it is one thing to complicate it, but another thing to give a lazy knee-jerk response to the moralizing crusades on a different side of the left (which I certainly do disagree with in principle, and I think obfuscate the genuine tragedy of this situation). You give a critique of the law in favor of socially-realized freedom while starting from a point of ideal freedom -- the very question "Can words really be dangerous?" is one that requires an Enlightenment-liberal framework to begin with. It starts from the ideal rather than the material. So ultimately, I think this entire discourse (and even my involvement in it with this very post) is really quite useless -- not saying that it shouldn't exist, but rather that it is a form of academic navel-gazing and hence shouldn't pretend that this particular strain of discourse is in any way useful. People should be talking about this, questioning it, I agree -- but not in this manner, which was sloppily done, insensitive, and largely besides the point. There is a right way to go about this kind of questioning (which I accept) and a wrong way, and this was certainly a wrong way. It is, as others have said, reliant upon rhetorics that are associated with rape culture.
So apologies if I find this particular exercise of the freedom of speech rather insidious -- removing moralizing from the question (which I agree with generally) doesn't mean that all speech is necessarily equivalent on some fundamental basis, nor does the power-knowledge schema which somebody like Foucault sets up mean that language is arbitrary if it is all caught up in power. Some speech is more implicated in particular forms of power (rape culture rhetoric) than others; it is a gradient of many different locations within the field of power, not a universal equivalence.
I appreciate your response. You make a lot of good points. Some of them are too high brow for their own good, but I understand and appreciate where you are coming from, especially because we need more men standing up against rape culture. It also sounds like there were ulterior motives and political alt-right operatives manipulating the discourse. I feel sorry for the good people at Sundial who got swept up in it.
Modern society is not about justice, but freedom. And Foucault called for the abolition of age of consent laws! And criticized sexual moralism. So if we’re bringing up him (why?) then he won’t be your ally in this.
You are not being “materialist” but simply proposing your own moral “idealism” against one for which you have distaste.
You haven’t written a criticism of this article. Your comment didn’t give the article more than a sentence or two. So there is no reason to address your “critique” — it doesn’t exist.
It would be helpful to your argument if you cited an example - just one - of the thoughtless and uncritical argument you decry. the fact that you don't leads me to believe you don't have the chops to do it. Or that you can't come up with one.
Huh? To whom are you responding, witchfinder general Hazel Pearson? Speech has consequences, per her words .. and there is a quick and justified consequence to someone publishing to the entire planet a defamatory and childish screed. The consequence is to her credibility and reputation. She has revealed herself as someone not to be hired to your workplace or to be put in care on your children. Perhaps she is qualified for a place on Robespierre's jury, or Joe McCarthy's staff. Actual Witchfinders and KKK lynch mobs are not currently hiring. Hazel Pearson is a public menace, a person who could ruin your child's life by publishing to the world one false accusation .. or even real accusation .. she heard about at college, and uses the corpse of your child's reputation to virtue signal to the world.
Ad hominem? Read Hazel Pearson's actual words. She is in favor of consequences for speech ... thus good for the gander. She is publishing defamatory screed published to the entire world .. a far wider and more fertile and more certain arena for recruiting vigilante lynch mobs than that roused to Emmit Till. Defamation of character, conviction without due process .. or even an arrest .. but even that would not inspire my disgust with this vile woman .. it would just have me think her stupid .. where she crossed the line was her advocacy of "consequences of free speech". No, there should be NO consequences for the act of expressing a thought, none .. no firing for belonging to an actual Nazi or Communist Party nor vocalizing their creeds, .. none. A firing for profanity to a customer or for not serving a customer wearing a Swastika or PETA slogan - those are not thoughts, but actions with measurable and direct impact on the employer's income .. Or we live in Hazel's world .. consequences for every breath by every busy body. So consequences for this Hazel Pearson until my very last breath. Per her request. She is an active danger to anyone who might think to employ her or invite her to a party. Or she can apologize.
(In short .. of course I agree with you .. though perhaps my illustration to Hazel of what her world would actually look like, if we all joined in .. will go over her head. Or perhaps I am just not as talented in making the point already made by authors as far ago as "judge not lest ye be judged" and "glass houses and stones" and such. Or even "illustrating absurdity by being absurd". (I will admit that I no longer suffer fools politely .. a very different me that before the still recent Woke/Covid/Metoo/SJW era .. until the horror show of McCarthyism 2.0 that played out here in ground zero of Portland Oregon .. I'd likely have considered myself one of 'em. Most of my actual liberal friends and family quietly moved away from the area without comment - with still nary a public admittance as to why - no comment due to it taking just one Hazel Pearson to give them a headache for life. But I digress. )
To the entire body of Sundial staff who allowed this utter piece of bullshit to reach the public: you should be ashamed of yourselves.
The particular line poking fun at the collective experience of women reading about the Cornell Rapists in the media, as you put it sarcastically: “all women’s experiences are represented in what happened to Doe,” is a much bigger deal than you might care to acknowledge. Half of all women have been sexually assaulted, a statistic purely based on what actually gets reported. So yes, the case at Cornell does indeed represent the experiences of many, many women.
“Women who have had degrading sexual experiences or moments where they felt used or humiliated can easily see themselves in Doe.” Are you kidding? Was reading the text that Thomas Newell sent, calling her “free pussy,” not enough empirical evidence of her rape to you people? Not everything needs the voice of “the devil’s advocate,” especially not cases like this.
“...At first it sounded cool, and doing it would mean she’s not a “prude,” but the aftermath left her feeling gross.” You are quite literally describing one of the many byproducts of the rape culture that we live within. With the amount of so-called “critical thinking” boasted by those in Sundial, I am surprised one didn't click for you—did you ever consider why you felt the need to “not be a prude”? I hope you find the ability to address your trauma; nonetheless, victim-blaming other women through this wordslop is pathetic. The real cherry on top was calling the rape a “drug-fueled orgy.” Absolutely distasteful, careless, and disturbing that these words were written in the first place.
Hazel, while I agree with much of your position on this topic about widespread outrage being justified, your remark about what should or shouldn’t be published is a bit tone deaf to me. Should we not publish opinions that aren’t majoritarian because some might view them as unacceptable? This article was not an endorsement of sexual assault. Whether you find nuance annoying or not is one thing—but you are, subconsciously or not, arguing that the speech of the authors should be policed/restricted BECAUSE of their position, which is dangerous territory for us all.
Not at all saying that we should police peoples’ free speech! They should, however, realize that free speech does NOT mean freedom from consequences. Turn those IG comments back on if you care so much about discourse and conversation.
I agree that speech is not free from consequences. And as you know I’m graduated and no longer in charge of Sundial or its Instagram. Wishing you well in the rest of your time at Columbia and thanks for the exchange.
Not one bit of outrage was justified .. perhaps at some annoyance at the frat president who reacted more like a dorm mom than a fraternity brother. If not for his attempt to conform to the new Victorian era standards, this would have been at most inspiration for a future Animal House comedy side sketch. Those of us who remember High School Spring breaks of the 1970s .. no restrictions by any authority or parent on High School drinking, btw .. because as seniors we were adults .. are evidently mostly trying to dig deeper as to why this is news at all .. surely there must be SOMETHING dark and secret going on. And for the record, if I found out my son (or daughter, both 30 now) had refrained from peeking into that open room out of some deference to some internet strangers potential judgement, I'd likely smack 'em. As they were raised to follow their curiosity and be suspicious of all taboos, and most suspicious of those who install them. The new Church, same as the old Church, just following their own gods and living their own hypocritical lives .. whatever Hazel Pearson is ashamed of or torn up about from her past (my guess is an abortion from her own sexual adventure gone awry), she cannot absolve herself of it by projecting and protecting Jane Doe. (Doubt Jane Doe was as careless as Hazel, she seems to have been around the block a few times, hats off to her).
It’s not “nuance” to equate the experience of ANY sexual assault survivors with some “liberal-induced” post-nut clarity. It’s not “nuance” to completely disregard the REAL effects of the violent rape culture that we all live and study in, which these writers completely failed to address. It’s simply blaming victims and disregarding that assault even occurred. Alex, you must remember that I previously JOINED Sundial because I agree with the sentiment of providing a space for discourse. This article is one strong example of why I left. Rather than promoting productive discourse, Sundial has merely provided a platform for hatred under the not-so-opaque veil of “nuance.”
Hey again Hazel — I totally understand and in fact agree with much of your perspective on this piece. That said, I think your criticism doesn’t quite engage with the actual argument being made in this piece (even if I agree with you) about examining the evidence of the horrible situation at Cornell more closely. I remember why you joined Sundial, and I also remember when you left. I think you were uncomfortable sharing a space with people who think very differently from you and me on the left, but to call them proponents of “hate speech” is a very strong accusation I think you should think about the meaning of more closely. That shouldn’t just be thrown around, even if you strongly disagree or even think such arguments are morally reprehensible. But, again, I understand and respect your frustration.
This is the problem and why situations as Cornell will continue. Cowardice.. Her entire diatribe is based on her emotions and instead of telling her that her emotions doesn't trump other emotions or that emotions don't drive legalities, you coddle her. Which then empowers her. People need to hear when they're being juvenile and closed minded.
What is wrong with you .. why is your heart so filled with hatred and judgement. Ad hominem is your go-to when faced with ambiguity, defamation your go-to weapon. Pray you never respond to a jury call, as your mind will have been made upon viewing the accused. Misandrist extraordinaire. The only thing newsworthy of this event is the Frat House President taking measures to prevent this woman from crashing his their parties and putting his stewards in such jeopardy again. College age men of today are in general emotionally less mature or experienced than women of their age. No stones should be cast .. this is a NORMAL - and quite fun - part of growing up .. the damage is done .. as with Emmitt Till, when the more mature woman involved becomes fearful of being shamed by the likes of Hazel Pearson and Cotton Mather.
Jane Doe’s testimony in 2024 described consensual sex, and drunken men who were surprisingly quick to back off when told no. Many of the comments here are utterly unhinged.
I've said it before and I'll say it again; I sincerely doubt that someone actually cares about the case at hand or the people involved if they choose to gloss over facts like these. The debate and the case instead become a tool to enforce their stance in the broader culture war. The calls to silence the authors of this piece are also a tell: an inconvenient analysis of the events cannot be allowed to exist, regardless of if it is based on facts, because it risks exposing the fragility of the entire conclusion that is actually based on an unproven premise (both to the crowd and to the very person making the claim).
But I do believe that these things occur subconsciously, or at least with a great degree of cognitive dissonance, which is why people tend to get so upset when you call them out on it. There is a way in which many of us were raised to always tend towards 'niceness' instead of critical thought. Jane Doe is a victim because she claims she is, the 'Cornell 7' are guilty because she claims they are (and because they are men), and any questioning of this narrative is considered unkind or even mean.
It's why some commenters here skip the step of engaging with the core arguments in the text and go straight to platitudes about sexual assault like 'Half of all women have been sexually assaulted'. The fact that the very nature of what happened that night gets called into question by the authors of this piece isn't even taken into consideration. Commenters move straight past the authors’ argument that the encounter was consensual in order to discuss the case as if the occurrence of sexual assault were already an established fact. Otherwise, the debate in the comments would revolve entirely around a back-and-forth discussing the facts of this case that might prove or disprove that sexual assault occurred in the first place.
It’s like the authors of this piece and the people commenting on it are talking to each other while having two different conversations; The authors discuss the events that took place from a perspective of consent, and the commenters do so from a perspective of assault. Those commenting refuse to even consider the former, because Jane Doe being a victim gets 'proven' by the mere fact that she claims to be one, and any further questioning is considered unkind to her and others who claim to be victims. But that does mean that the actual productive conversation never takes place, because every time someone contrarily claims to disagree with the notion that sexual assault took place to begin with, they get met with a response from someone who has taken it as an indisputable truth that it in fact did. So they respond as if you have just denied something that has already been proven beyond any reasonable doubt, and conveniently leave the actual productive discussion of the facts and details in their dust. It’s like the authors of this piece are playing chess while the commenters try to beat them by playing checkers, and anytime the former tries to explain why their opponent can’t beat them by jumping over their chess pieces and taking them off the board, the latter claims that this just makes them a sore loser.
So I really don’t think that those who oppose this piece in the way they do give a damn about the case itself or Jane Doe. Their unwillingness to engage with the details of this case undermines their credibility as genuine participants who want to figure out what really happened and how to respond to it, and shows that they are much more interested in defending a position that they are already settled on. And that is certainly not doing future Jane Doe’s who may actually be victims any favors.
And to top it off by claiming that you support free speech while also wanting to ensure that certain speech has ‘consequences’... Artificially imposed consequences like silencing or deplatforming are the very things that go against free speech. Free means free: you can say anything you want except yelling ‘Fire!’ in a crowded building (or perhaps calls for or threats of physical violence). The only consequence to that free speech can be criticism, which itself is allowed to take any form (critical, harsh, or even outright derogatory), because it too is free.
I don’t understand what is happening at these Ivy League universities. Sometimes I wish that I had been able to study there, sometimes I’m glad that I dodged the bullet.
As you said, these are common subconscious (or cognitive) distortions - certainly not unique to Ivy League students, anywhere with an ideological bubble however would have the problem exacerbated though
Okay, flip the script then. John Doe signs up for a sexy threesome. Gets drunk to the point of passing out. More sorority sisters show up, seven of them, all of them jumping on for a ride (they use mechanical methods to keep John's, err, little johnson, deployable). They post the same texts.
...did John consent to underage drinking and sex beyond that sexy threesome? Are the sorority sisters charged with anything? Does John try to sue them for civil damages? Are the seven sisters all named by newspapers? Does the court of public opinion condemn the sisters as rapists?
Does it? Answer my question. Where is the mass outcry for the John Does of the world when they are sexually abused by women in power over them? Who is actually pretending rape isn't a very serious crime that should be pursued without destroying jurisprudence or the reputations (or even lives) of the accused, especially if the accused could be plausibly innocent of some or even all charges?
WHY ARE WE BEING ASKED TO LYNCH THE CORNELL SEVEN BY A FROTHING ANGRY MOB, BOB?!?
Who are you ashamed of? The ones who wrote the article and take Jane Doe's description from 2024 about what transpired seriously or the ones in the comments who insist that she was raped because she said she was raped and ignore her description of what transpired?
She was not raped by any definition of the word. This scene was one we all (mostly in vain) hoped and strived to at least witness at high school spring break events. If not for the frat President taking measures to prevent such shenanigans in the future due to liability concerns, by barring drunken female party crashers, all involved, of all sexes, would have all emerged wiser and more experienced and confident. As it ever was. (It was the noble woman who hosted the orgies, not the peasantry.)
I’ll be the one to tell you: we don’t take this seriously anymore btw. It’s not a serious position and those with an IQ above about 2 digits are done pretending what you say is anything other than mindless, hate filled drivel
"Half of all women have been sexually assaulted, a statistic purely based on what actually gets reported."
Sources appear to differ on this.
"An estimated 301,580 people ages 12 and up are harmed by sexual violence every year in the U.S., according to the National Crime Victimization Survey."
Not sure where this person gets such a statistic, pretty sure that level of sexual assault doesn't even happen with roving gape gangs looking for easy targets!
What statistic is fabricated? And when you do your research, you’ll note that the strongest caveat you’ll come across is that sexual assault is one of the most underreported crimes in history. So, take whatever number you find and multiply it.
And I see no “therapy speak” in this cogent and logical comment. Consider just the phrase “free pussy.” That directly implies that normally, pussy has a cost to it, and here’s some that you can get without paying anything. You don’t see what’s so terribly bad about the mind that would post that phrase on social media?
But that is true. Normally, men can't have sex with women for "free." That's just reality. Women generally expect to be paid in terms of love, affection, or at least erotic pleasure. Here, the woman didn't demand much of anything.
Thank you for proving my point. You see sex as something that men “get” from women, not something that men and women equally share. You see sex as payment for something you give to a woman. Perhaps you wouldn’t give things like love and affection to women unless they first give you sex, raising the question of what those words actually mean to you.
Perhaps you say that because it’s been your experience — no woman has ever wanted to have sex with you because she wanted to, without receiving something in return. Or, perhaps that’s just the way you see women, and sex, and the world.
As for the "free pussy" comment, feminists claim that rape is supposedly usually about power, not "pussy". So the comment would appear to suggest the individual involved is *not* a rapist according to feminist dogma at least.
The issue is more with humanity adapting to the phenomenon of social media rather than with the phrase .. which to me is entirely apropos and banal for the demographic expressing it. It is just that until now, shuck and jive in the moment was not published in stone to the planet and for eternity.
I'm here just to call out comments that shit on this article without actually engaging with any of the article's arguments! Come on, if you take issue with the article then surely you can muster up some actual reasons ...
It's one thing for an article to evoke negative response to the substance of the article. The author is free to speak - and the readers are free to speak in disagreement - absolutely. But what is troubling to me as a 53 year old woman, feminist, leftist, attorney - is when people go beyond panning an article - or vigorously disputing its substance - to wanting/ demanding/ feeling entitled to "consequences" for the author, and even the publisher! This punitive, reactionary, proverbial *pearl clutching* zeitgeist - is anathema to the "marketplace of ideas," a cornerstone of American political philosophy. True- the First Amendment only applies to government actors. But the philosophical tenet on which it rests is broadly applicable, and Americans typically agree in the abstract that we benefit as a society from a free marketplace of ideas. So why the knee jerk inclination to get heads on stakes.
To quote John Stuart Mill for the Columbia core curriculum crowd - "[T]he peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error." In short: attack the speech not the speaker (and certainly not the publisher).
Also, some of the article was lazy and I think a bit tone deaf failing to recognize how triggered women are by this and reflecting more seriously about why that is (If it's hysterical; it's historical.) But the issues are not black and white in that case. My friend and criminal defense attorney Tiffany Blacknell (@lwyrchc) is covering this case going over the charges against each of the 7 guys - because it is not fair to lump them all together. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DecbfxzvkNF/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! I really appreciate your perspective as someone outside of the Columbia “bubble.” I hope we can all learn and build off of each other and respectfully, intelligently, disagree!
Thanks, everyone involved with the article and subsequent discussion is well advised to listen and learn from the opposing viewpoints, but as a mother and fully grown adult, I beseech everyone to take any *lessons learned* in stride. No one should be attacked as a *person* for writing or publishing or defending an article. You digital native Gen Zers have a harder life than Gen X ever did (don't believe the internet hype). Protect your mental health, dears/ : )
'"doing anything more" than walking into the room, doing ketamine, and leaving.' Meaning he was a witness and did not report or do anything to stop it -- and entered the room after receiving the message.
Since Cornell did not do enough to punish these criminals, there are social measures in place. Being plastered all over the internet is a social repercussion for rape, assault, and bystanding these crimes -- and a mild one compared to civil or criminal trials. And it is a (hopefully) successful discouragement and cautionary measure for future potential offenders.
but you are ignoring her agency. i will retract if the facts are different than i understand them, i'm not professing to have them all, which is precisely why I have not passed full judgment. It sounds wild to me but the woman was agreeing and consenting to much of what sounds wild to me, right? Are you suggesting that someone who walks into a room, sees all this sees a woman seemingly freely doing ketamine and engaging in sexual activities is obligated now to report htat woman because she couldn't possibly be exercising free will. I think this is the point the article was touching upon, even if clumsily and too cavalierly. (is that a word? lol)
Does he have some duty to report fornication that the woman had supposedly agreed to? Was there criminal rape going on in that room? What if these men were black, or muslim, or homosexual, or transwomen? :)
Uh oh, that’s two ‘tisms from Ms. Jane Doe, according to the oppression olympics, unless the moslem and black having penises cancels the oppression of religion and race out? I’m not smart enough to play that game, alas…
> at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don't think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,
If you are referring to Scott K., he was absolved by the university of doing Ketamine off of Jane Doe. She did not allege in her statement that she saw him do it and admitted she did not see him do this. He produced a negative drug test for Ketamine.
Of course, while Jane Doe says he and the other Scott were asking if she was okay neither called an Uber to get her home.
Beyond the (numerous) ways in which this piece is morally repugnant in its seemingly either ignorant or shameless reliance on basic rape culture rhetoric, this is also just...really bad journalism? The facts of the case mentioned are neither comprehensive nor up to date
Typical leftist. Throwing a hissy fit tantrum and appealing to emotion instead of presenting a logical argument.
> at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don't think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,
Yep, I'm waiting. I just want to call out comments that shit on this article without actually engaging with any of the article's arguments! Come on, if you take issue with the article then surely you can muster up some actual reasons ...
so rich to assert that the public is infantilizing Jane Doe by treating her account of her own assault as true…when you undermine her ability to understand the reality of the brutal violence she experienced and attempt to write it off as her simply rejecting her own ability to make “bad decisions”. it is not infantilizing to say that women are being assaulted and it’s honestly disgusting that you think so. this is not “good faith discourse”
Which Jane Doe am I supposed to believe, Jane Doe before the sex, Jane Doe before campus police, or Jane Doe after apparently some internet chatroom convinced her she was totally raped?
Jane Doe’s story has been consistent and is believable. While her interpretation of what happened has changed and she is drawing different conclusions the underlying facts are essentially the same.
so what are the facts of the case as we have them, because i keep getting two different versions: "Jane Doe, Girl Gone Wild" versus "Jane Doe, Lifetime Movie of the Week"
The reason there appears to be inconsistencies between her statement to police and her civil Complaint is due to the fact that the Complaint is written in conclusory language. In other words, because it alleged that Jane Doe had consumed enough alcohol to be unable legally to provide consent (even if, subjectively, at the time she may not have considered herself to be that drunk). So her evidence states that she was “5 or 6 out of 10” drunk and agreed to a threesome she was "excited" about, which then occurred. The civil Complaint states: "In her drunken state, Plaintiff was incapable of consenting" and that sex was "forced" upon her.
That sounds very different! But if you strip away the conclusory language they are in agreement with the underlying facts: she was drunk, she agreed to a threesome, the threesome occured. The difference is that her subjective opinion at the time as that she was 5-6/10 drunk and the civil Complaint asserts that that level of intoxication (based on 12+ drinks in a short amount of time as well as, potentially Ketamine), as a legal matter, means that any consent must be vitiated. You do not need to agree with her lawyers' legal theory to believe her evidence.
The only inconsistencies that I could find are minor and appear to be errors by her lawyer (e.g. she was a sophomore, not a junior and one of the defendants left the room, which is not noted in her civil Complaint).
> Jane Doe’s story has been consistent and is believable.
"at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don't think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,"
Yes that is what I said, her interpretation of what happened has changed but the underlying facts are the same. She noted she was "excited" about the first threesome and agreed to it (i.e. the threesome she is texting Newell about).
As a longtime card-carrying , 90s-women’s-college feminist I support having this conversation. Nothing should be off limits, and Paglia’s perspective has long been debated in the feminist canon. Please don’t freak out about an article in a free speech publication, off all things, now.✌️
I used to be a second-wave egalitarian, until I took the black pill suppository of "nobody actually gave a fuck about equality except for us mooks, it was about using us for power, socialism where women are the proletariat, a utopia where the bottom 90% of men are all liquidated, victimhood grievance narratives forever" :(
Makes me proud to be a Barnard grad. Beautifully written. I know you both are coming from a place of compassion. In college, the desire to break through boundaries can be so strong.
I am an in my 50s, an attorney, a feminist, a career woman in a field dominated by men who has had to fight when necessary for equal treatment and against discrimination. And I am very relieved to see that you have said what so many are thinking. Couldn't have said it better myself. I want you to know how much publishing this article is appreciated by many.
Thank you for sharing your perspective! I hope more people understand that our opinion really isn’t extreme “rage-bait,” and that many people share it too!
I'm here just to call out comments that shit on this article without actually engaging with any of the article's arguments! Come on, if you take issue with the article then surely you can muster up some actual reasons ...
This is one of the best articles I have read about this incident and the entire social problematic. Thank you for writing it.
It is astonishing how much can be written about a subject without making any true progress or original contribution in the debate. This piece, I think, is the rare example of an honest attempt to tackle the issue beyond the usual performative listing of talking points. We need much more of that. Especially because the typical article (and many of the response articles I have seen) can probably be better written by AI these days.
Thank you for this and I hope to hear more from you.
Well done. This piece challenges the mob mentality that has dominated this story from the beginning. My core values steer me towards supporting and believing women when they say they have been victimized, but, I would ask the question: are all women telling the truth about these things every single time? Is it disgraceful to simply analyze the event on its own merit and allow for a dissenting view? When I was in college, I went to a bar and ended up having drinks with a girl that I had met before but didn't really know that well. Unknown to me that night was that she had a big crush on one of my close friends. We got drunk and she lavished me with public displays of affection that was noticed by all in our group. She came back to my apartment with me and we had sex (used her condom). At no point were either of us so drunk that we could not give consent. She left that night and shortly afterwards starts telling people that I had raped her. She had men in our town trying to hunt me down. Turns out, she just didn't want my friend, who she liked, to know that she had willingly had sex with me because she thought it would ruin her chances with him. In the end, when things started getting out of hand, she confessed that she made the story up. So, from my experience, the whole "all women should be believed all of the time" is met with a certain degree of skepticism because I know that women, like men, sometimes lie. This does not mean that I never believe women when they say they are abused; I just think that the possibility exists that stories can be fabricated when there are motivations for doing so.
A basic liberalism (in the real not derogatory sense of the term) would mean allowing women to have a variety of sexual experiences without labeling them as victims and not treating young men as “predators” or calling for punitive action by the state because of what happened in the bedroom. The Paglia quote is good — sexual freedom means freedom for a variety of experience without training wheels or safeguards. Though, I would say that there should be no reason a young woman has to feel ashamed or degraded by a “taboo” sexual experience, except that the social taboo exists. A truly free sexuality would allow for a more open-ended relationship to sexual experience, not resolving ambiguity into “good” and “bad,” even less “dignity” or “shame,” so long as the experience was entered upon freely. On this point I must disagree with Christina, though I sympathize with her experience.
Good on Nikos and Christina for bravely voicing their thoughts on a difficult topic. Do not mind the people freaking out. Responding to speech with anger, fear or violence is always right-wing and reactionary — indicative of an authoritarian personality. Sundial should stand by its authors! It is never wrong to stand up for what is right against the mob — and to defend our ability to hear a variety of perspectives, however potentially offensive or strange to us, is indeed righteous.
As a longtime card-carrying , 90s-women’s-college feminist I support having this conversation. Nothing should be off limits, and Paglia’s perspective has long been debated in the feminist canon. Please don’t freak out about an article in a free speech publication, off all things, now.✌️
I am same as you and think similiarly.
Thanks Erin! Good to get your perspective, as always. And this means the world, truly.
That it is now considered 'brave' to express an opinion that was considered common sense by every generation up until the present one, is for me the only issue of interest to me in all this. How did this happen? And what lessons can be drawn? The obvious one is we are seeing the consequence of raising a generation of children with few siblings and completely protected from 'bullying', free unsupervised play, and rough-housing.
Safe space? Trigger warnings? But look at the fecklessness of the (mostly) old white men in congress, and it's hard to blame the younger generation.
Well yeah, they ARE politicians (that Trump is very much not is what made him refreshing for a while) .. but at what point does fecklessness segue into senility and puppetry. Their job is to breathe, provide the illusion of grownups in charge, while someone else moves their fingers to sign a page .. from McConnell to Biden .. to Diane Feinstein. Pelosi may be the only one, for better and worse, who kept her wits and spoke for herself to the very end. But yes, you have a point.
The Paglia quote is pretty bad. No, this not true: if a “young man says to you, ‘Would you like to go up to my room?’ I’m sorry, ok, you are consenting to sex.”
If you’re a young man who invited a girl up to your room and she agrees that doesn’t mean she wants to have sex with you. She might! But the mere agreement to go upstairs doesn’t mean she’s consenting to sex.
Congrats, you just infantilized women. If a woman can't figure out that "go up to my room" in a frat house is a euphemism for sex, then she has the mental maturity of a 5-year old.
It's a pretty reasonable assumption that "would you like to go up to my room?" means that the frat guy wants to have sex with her. It does not follow, morally or legally, that her going up to said room means that she has consented to sex with him.
Yes, it does follow, because of what's called the "reasonable person test", both morally and legally.
In Paglia's day that was the shared understanding, because the man was usually enough of a gentleman to not just ask for sex very directly, that's her point, unless you can clearly communicate "yes sex", "no sex", you end up in the gray zone of dubious consent where one side assumes something and the other side assumes something else,
The statement is that an agreement to go up to someone's room is "consenting to sex". Not that there's a gray zone, or assumptions, that the woman is "consenting to sex". Which is untrue.
Again, depends on the era and the culture. Camille lived in a culture where “go up to a man’s room” meant having sex with him, without having to spell that out. I don’t know if we still have that culture anywhere, which is why I said: “hey if some guy invites you up to his room you’d better make sure it’s not for anything you don’t want” (it’s why i eventually broke up with my boyfriend, he kept wanting to fornicate with me and I didn’t want to fornicate with anybody)
https://youtube.com/watch?v=9A7ViXyDVVc&is=zY-plsE7buLyas3B
Paglia’s phrasing is a rhetorical device. She’s not literally consenting to sex. This scene from a now-ancient movie beautifully illustrates … something. Not sure how to describe it but it seems directly relevant to the larger dialog, both in the Sundial piece and these comments. It starts slow, but be patient: it’s only 2 minutes long.
I'm not sure what rhetorical device that would be...
You're right, it's not a rhetorical device. I should have said, "she's describing a truth about how men and women naturally relate to one another, another aspect of which is depicted amusingly in the movie Tootsie." Or something like that.
I hope it gave you a cuckle.
"Responding to speech with anger, fear or violence is always right-wing and reactionary..."
Mao, Stalin, Robespierre... history's right-wing reactionaries.
I had a similar response and was ready to click "reply" when I remembered the Bolsheviks used to talk about "right" and "left." That poster seems to be pretty deep into academic Marxism.
Claude summarized it as below, but the sequence is reversed. Stalin got rid of Trotsky and then proceeded to implement the Left's program ... which he blamed on the Right, who he then liquidated. (Or something like that.)
"In Bolshevik usage, “right” meant gradualism (NEP, concessions to the peasantry), while “left” meant rapid industrialization, world revolution, and often more coercion.
"Bukharin’s Right Opposition opposed forced collectivization. The Left Communists of 1918 were the ones who wanted revolutionary war.
"Trotsky, a “left” figure, advocated militarizing labor and crushed Kronstadt.
"Stalin posed as a centrist, defeated the Left, then the Right, and ended up the most authoritarian of all."
But they were all Marxists.
It's not indicative of "authoritarianism" or "censorship" when people are called out for making a genuinely thoughtless and uncritical argument devoid of any self-awareness. It's not a freedom to be lazy and bad with your reasoning, or just say whatever you want and expect everybody to defend it on the basis of unilateral "free speech."Freedom of speech means freedom to shit on people who are just generally bad at speaking -- per your definition of freedom, right? ;)
It's one thing for an article to evoke negative response to the substance of the article. The author is free to speak - and the readers are free to speak in disagreement - absolutely. But what is troubling to me as a 53 year old woman, feminist, leftist, attorney - is when people go beyond panning an article - or vigorously disputing its substance - to wanting/ demanding/ feeling entitled to "consequences" for the author, and even the publisher! This punitive, reactionary, proverbial *pearl clutching* zeitgeist - is anathema to the "marketplace of ideas," a cornerstone of American political philosophy. True- the First Amendment only applies to government actors. But the philosophical tenet on which it rests is broadly applicable, and Americans typically agree in the abstract that we benefit as a society from a free marketplace of ideas. So why the knee jerk inclination to get heads on stakes.
To quote John Stuart Mill for the Columbia core curriculum crowd - "[T]he peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error."
So yes, attack the SPEECH, not the SPEAKER (and certainly not the Publisher). Some of the article was lazy and/or insensitive. But the truth is that the issues are not black and white in that case. My friend from law school, Tiffany Blacknell (@lwyrchc) is covering this case in an unbiased way, going over the charges against each of the 7 guys - because they should NOT be lumped all together. At least one of the guys as I understand is not accused of doing anything more than walking into the room, doing ketamine, and leaving. It is only fair to consider the allegations against the guys separately. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DecbfxzvkNF/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
I agree with lawditory (my fellow leftist!) that the pearl clutching response has been bad for thinking.
You are at liberty to respond to speech in an authoritarian manner, yes! Of course you have that right. And society has the freedom to descend into utter thoughtlessness and aggression. But the task of critical thought — and may I say of the Left — is to reflect openly on the variety of forms the ideology of our time takes. Freedom must be realized socially, it is not determined merely by law.
The many thoughtless and insubstantial condemnations of this article and its authors, including death threats, are about shutting down any discussion. They are the result of an hysterical sex panic. Most people decided the words were “dangerous” before even reading it. Can words really be dangerous? If this article is “dangerous” then what about articles commenting on war or revolution, events which actually involve the loss of life of hundreds, thousands or even millions of people? Clearly the response is overblown. People are so intolerant of the variety of sexual experience that they cannot stand to even read what these authors have written.
Yes, I was attacking the speech, not the speaker. We are on the same page there. I'm against moralizing witch-hunts that are unfounded on genuine critique. At the same time, I do think that I did openly reflect on this matter; what I say in response to the freedom of speech *is* precisely my stance. At the same moment you condemn people for launching insubstantial condemnations of this article and its authors, you extrapolate my critique to a moralizing one; the same moment you push for genuine critique, you misrecognize my genuine critique as something else, something secondary. That is not the case. The fact of the matter is that there are rhetorics that are dangerous, and the response to them should neither be libertarian nor authoritarian: it is not that the 'left' and the 'right' exist on a spectrum, and that they are quantitatively equivalent with the same weight, just inverted. Their relationship is much more complicated than a horizontal one; there is as some might say a power relation between what we consider to be the sides. That said, yes, some rhetorics are innately tied to the exercise of power in certain functions, but that is no basis to make any moral (generalized) judgments -- that is just how it works.
At the same time, all this constitutional-liberal, idealist, high-brow and removed intellectual onanism is not productive to attaining real material justice. I've yet to hear a case as to why this article is genuinely assisting the discourse -- it is one thing to complicate it, but another thing to give a lazy knee-jerk response to the moralizing crusades on a different side of the left (which I certainly do disagree with in principle, and I think obfuscate the genuine tragedy of this situation). You give a critique of the law in favor of socially-realized freedom while starting from a point of ideal freedom -- the very question "Can words really be dangerous?" is one that requires an Enlightenment-liberal framework to begin with. It starts from the ideal rather than the material. So ultimately, I think this entire discourse (and even my involvement in it with this very post) is really quite useless -- not saying that it shouldn't exist, but rather that it is a form of academic navel-gazing and hence shouldn't pretend that this particular strain of discourse is in any way useful. People should be talking about this, questioning it, I agree -- but not in this manner, which was sloppily done, insensitive, and largely besides the point. There is a right way to go about this kind of questioning (which I accept) and a wrong way, and this was certainly a wrong way. It is, as others have said, reliant upon rhetorics that are associated with rape culture.
So apologies if I find this particular exercise of the freedom of speech rather insidious -- removing moralizing from the question (which I agree with generally) doesn't mean that all speech is necessarily equivalent on some fundamental basis, nor does the power-knowledge schema which somebody like Foucault sets up mean that language is arbitrary if it is all caught up in power. Some speech is more implicated in particular forms of power (rape culture rhetoric) than others; it is a gradient of many different locations within the field of power, not a universal equivalence.
I appreciate your response. You make a lot of good points. Some of them are too high brow for their own good, but I understand and appreciate where you are coming from, especially because we need more men standing up against rape culture. It also sounds like there were ulterior motives and political alt-right operatives manipulating the discourse. I feel sorry for the good people at Sundial who got swept up in it.
Modern society is not about justice, but freedom. And Foucault called for the abolition of age of consent laws! And criticized sexual moralism. So if we’re bringing up him (why?) then he won’t be your ally in this.
You are not being “materialist” but simply proposing your own moral “idealism” against one for which you have distaste.
You haven’t written a criticism of this article. Your comment didn’t give the article more than a sentence or two. So there is no reason to address your “critique” — it doesn’t exist.
It would be helpful to your argument if you cited an example - just one - of the thoughtless and uncritical argument you decry. the fact that you don't leads me to believe you don't have the chops to do it. Or that you can't come up with one.
Huh? To whom are you responding, witchfinder general Hazel Pearson? Speech has consequences, per her words .. and there is a quick and justified consequence to someone publishing to the entire planet a defamatory and childish screed. The consequence is to her credibility and reputation. She has revealed herself as someone not to be hired to your workplace or to be put in care on your children. Perhaps she is qualified for a place on Robespierre's jury, or Joe McCarthy's staff. Actual Witchfinders and KKK lynch mobs are not currently hiring. Hazel Pearson is a public menace, a person who could ruin your child's life by publishing to the world one false accusation .. or even real accusation .. she heard about at college, and uses the corpse of your child's reputation to virtue signal to the world.
Do you realize you are doing exactly what you are proclaiming to stand against? Hypocrites are the worst. Leave your ad hominem attacks at home.
Ad hominem? Read Hazel Pearson's actual words. She is in favor of consequences for speech ... thus good for the gander. She is publishing defamatory screed published to the entire world .. a far wider and more fertile and more certain arena for recruiting vigilante lynch mobs than that roused to Emmit Till. Defamation of character, conviction without due process .. or even an arrest .. but even that would not inspire my disgust with this vile woman .. it would just have me think her stupid .. where she crossed the line was her advocacy of "consequences of free speech". No, there should be NO consequences for the act of expressing a thought, none .. no firing for belonging to an actual Nazi or Communist Party nor vocalizing their creeds, .. none. A firing for profanity to a customer or for not serving a customer wearing a Swastika or PETA slogan - those are not thoughts, but actions with measurable and direct impact on the employer's income .. Or we live in Hazel's world .. consequences for every breath by every busy body. So consequences for this Hazel Pearson until my very last breath. Per her request. She is an active danger to anyone who might think to employ her or invite her to a party. Or she can apologize.
(In short .. of course I agree with you .. though perhaps my illustration to Hazel of what her world would actually look like, if we all joined in .. will go over her head. Or perhaps I am just not as talented in making the point already made by authors as far ago as "judge not lest ye be judged" and "glass houses and stones" and such. Or even "illustrating absurdity by being absurd". (I will admit that I no longer suffer fools politely .. a very different me that before the still recent Woke/Covid/Metoo/SJW era .. until the horror show of McCarthyism 2.0 that played out here in ground zero of Portland Oregon .. I'd likely have considered myself one of 'em. Most of my actual liberal friends and family quietly moved away from the area without comment - with still nary a public admittance as to why - no comment due to it taking just one Hazel Pearson to give them a headache for life. But I digress. )
🔥🔥🙌🙌🙌
Don't listen to the haters in the comments guys. This was a well-reasoned and well-written piece. Well done!
Thank you so much!
Thank you!
It's a very poorly written and thought out piece. What are you talking about?
How is it poorly written?
To the entire body of Sundial staff who allowed this utter piece of bullshit to reach the public: you should be ashamed of yourselves.
The particular line poking fun at the collective experience of women reading about the Cornell Rapists in the media, as you put it sarcastically: “all women’s experiences are represented in what happened to Doe,” is a much bigger deal than you might care to acknowledge. Half of all women have been sexually assaulted, a statistic purely based on what actually gets reported. So yes, the case at Cornell does indeed represent the experiences of many, many women.
“Women who have had degrading sexual experiences or moments where they felt used or humiliated can easily see themselves in Doe.” Are you kidding? Was reading the text that Thomas Newell sent, calling her “free pussy,” not enough empirical evidence of her rape to you people? Not everything needs the voice of “the devil’s advocate,” especially not cases like this.
“...At first it sounded cool, and doing it would mean she’s not a “prude,” but the aftermath left her feeling gross.” You are quite literally describing one of the many byproducts of the rape culture that we live within. With the amount of so-called “critical thinking” boasted by those in Sundial, I am surprised one didn't click for you—did you ever consider why you felt the need to “not be a prude”? I hope you find the ability to address your trauma; nonetheless, victim-blaming other women through this wordslop is pathetic. The real cherry on top was calling the rape a “drug-fueled orgy.” Absolutely distasteful, careless, and disturbing that these words were written in the first place.
Hazel, while I agree with much of your position on this topic about widespread outrage being justified, your remark about what should or shouldn’t be published is a bit tone deaf to me. Should we not publish opinions that aren’t majoritarian because some might view them as unacceptable? This article was not an endorsement of sexual assault. Whether you find nuance annoying or not is one thing—but you are, subconsciously or not, arguing that the speech of the authors should be policed/restricted BECAUSE of their position, which is dangerous territory for us all.
Not at all saying that we should police peoples’ free speech! They should, however, realize that free speech does NOT mean freedom from consequences. Turn those IG comments back on if you care so much about discourse and conversation.
The consequence of your own published comment is to reveal yourself as a lynch mob Witchfinder General. You did this, Hazel Pearson:
https://sceneonradio.org/episode-30-movement-time/
I agree that speech is not free from consequences. And as you know I’m graduated and no longer in charge of Sundial or its Instagram. Wishing you well in the rest of your time at Columbia and thanks for the exchange.
Not one bit of outrage was justified .. perhaps at some annoyance at the frat president who reacted more like a dorm mom than a fraternity brother. If not for his attempt to conform to the new Victorian era standards, this would have been at most inspiration for a future Animal House comedy side sketch. Those of us who remember High School Spring breaks of the 1970s .. no restrictions by any authority or parent on High School drinking, btw .. because as seniors we were adults .. are evidently mostly trying to dig deeper as to why this is news at all .. surely there must be SOMETHING dark and secret going on. And for the record, if I found out my son (or daughter, both 30 now) had refrained from peeking into that open room out of some deference to some internet strangers potential judgement, I'd likely smack 'em. As they were raised to follow their curiosity and be suspicious of all taboos, and most suspicious of those who install them. The new Church, same as the old Church, just following their own gods and living their own hypocritical lives .. whatever Hazel Pearson is ashamed of or torn up about from her past (my guess is an abortion from her own sexual adventure gone awry), she cannot absolve herself of it by projecting and protecting Jane Doe. (Doubt Jane Doe was as careless as Hazel, she seems to have been around the block a few times, hats off to her).
It’s not “nuance” to equate the experience of ANY sexual assault survivors with some “liberal-induced” post-nut clarity. It’s not “nuance” to completely disregard the REAL effects of the violent rape culture that we all live and study in, which these writers completely failed to address. It’s simply blaming victims and disregarding that assault even occurred. Alex, you must remember that I previously JOINED Sundial because I agree with the sentiment of providing a space for discourse. This article is one strong example of why I left. Rather than promoting productive discourse, Sundial has merely provided a platform for hatred under the not-so-opaque veil of “nuance.”
Hey again Hazel — I totally understand and in fact agree with much of your perspective on this piece. That said, I think your criticism doesn’t quite engage with the actual argument being made in this piece (even if I agree with you) about examining the evidence of the horrible situation at Cornell more closely. I remember why you joined Sundial, and I also remember when you left. I think you were uncomfortable sharing a space with people who think very differently from you and me on the left, but to call them proponents of “hate speech” is a very strong accusation I think you should think about the meaning of more closely. That shouldn’t just be thrown around, even if you strongly disagree or even think such arguments are morally reprehensible. But, again, I understand and respect your frustration.
This is the problem and why situations as Cornell will continue. Cowardice.. Her entire diatribe is based on her emotions and instead of telling her that her emotions doesn't trump other emotions or that emotions don't drive legalities, you coddle her. Which then empowers her. People need to hear when they're being juvenile and closed minded.
What is wrong with you .. why is your heart so filled with hatred and judgement. Ad hominem is your go-to when faced with ambiguity, defamation your go-to weapon. Pray you never respond to a jury call, as your mind will have been made upon viewing the accused. Misandrist extraordinaire. The only thing newsworthy of this event is the Frat House President taking measures to prevent this woman from crashing his their parties and putting his stewards in such jeopardy again. College age men of today are in general emotionally less mature or experienced than women of their age. No stones should be cast .. this is a NORMAL - and quite fun - part of growing up .. the damage is done .. as with Emmitt Till, when the more mature woman involved becomes fearful of being shamed by the likes of Hazel Pearson and Cotton Mather.
Sending a text is actually not the definition of rape.
Didn't the texts released initially by TMZ paint a slightly different picture?
https://www.the-sun.com/news/17135256/cornell-text-jane-doe-leaked-messages-accusers-frat-bros/
Not saying that the men involved should be proud of their actions, but I'm not sure the texts paint a non consensual image of that night.
Jane Doe’s testimony in 2024 described consensual sex, and drunken men who were surprisingly quick to back off when told no. Many of the comments here are utterly unhinged.
I've said it before and I'll say it again; I sincerely doubt that someone actually cares about the case at hand or the people involved if they choose to gloss over facts like these. The debate and the case instead become a tool to enforce their stance in the broader culture war. The calls to silence the authors of this piece are also a tell: an inconvenient analysis of the events cannot be allowed to exist, regardless of if it is based on facts, because it risks exposing the fragility of the entire conclusion that is actually based on an unproven premise (both to the crowd and to the very person making the claim).
But I do believe that these things occur subconsciously, or at least with a great degree of cognitive dissonance, which is why people tend to get so upset when you call them out on it. There is a way in which many of us were raised to always tend towards 'niceness' instead of critical thought. Jane Doe is a victim because she claims she is, the 'Cornell 7' are guilty because she claims they are (and because they are men), and any questioning of this narrative is considered unkind or even mean.
It's why some commenters here skip the step of engaging with the core arguments in the text and go straight to platitudes about sexual assault like 'Half of all women have been sexually assaulted'. The fact that the very nature of what happened that night gets called into question by the authors of this piece isn't even taken into consideration. Commenters move straight past the authors’ argument that the encounter was consensual in order to discuss the case as if the occurrence of sexual assault were already an established fact. Otherwise, the debate in the comments would revolve entirely around a back-and-forth discussing the facts of this case that might prove or disprove that sexual assault occurred in the first place.
It’s like the authors of this piece and the people commenting on it are talking to each other while having two different conversations; The authors discuss the events that took place from a perspective of consent, and the commenters do so from a perspective of assault. Those commenting refuse to even consider the former, because Jane Doe being a victim gets 'proven' by the mere fact that she claims to be one, and any further questioning is considered unkind to her and others who claim to be victims. But that does mean that the actual productive conversation never takes place, because every time someone contrarily claims to disagree with the notion that sexual assault took place to begin with, they get met with a response from someone who has taken it as an indisputable truth that it in fact did. So they respond as if you have just denied something that has already been proven beyond any reasonable doubt, and conveniently leave the actual productive discussion of the facts and details in their dust. It’s like the authors of this piece are playing chess while the commenters try to beat them by playing checkers, and anytime the former tries to explain why their opponent can’t beat them by jumping over their chess pieces and taking them off the board, the latter claims that this just makes them a sore loser.
So I really don’t think that those who oppose this piece in the way they do give a damn about the case itself or Jane Doe. Their unwillingness to engage with the details of this case undermines their credibility as genuine participants who want to figure out what really happened and how to respond to it, and shows that they are much more interested in defending a position that they are already settled on. And that is certainly not doing future Jane Doe’s who may actually be victims any favors.
And to top it off by claiming that you support free speech while also wanting to ensure that certain speech has ‘consequences’... Artificially imposed consequences like silencing or deplatforming are the very things that go against free speech. Free means free: you can say anything you want except yelling ‘Fire!’ in a crowded building (or perhaps calls for or threats of physical violence). The only consequence to that free speech can be criticism, which itself is allowed to take any form (critical, harsh, or even outright derogatory), because it too is free.
I don’t understand what is happening at these Ivy League universities. Sometimes I wish that I had been able to study there, sometimes I’m glad that I dodged the bullet.
As you said, these are common subconscious (or cognitive) distortions - certainly not unique to Ivy League students, anywhere with an ideological bubble however would have the problem exacerbated though
Okay, flip the script then. John Doe signs up for a sexy threesome. Gets drunk to the point of passing out. More sorority sisters show up, seven of them, all of them jumping on for a ride (they use mechanical methods to keep John's, err, little johnson, deployable). They post the same texts.
...did John consent to underage drinking and sex beyond that sexy threesome? Are the sorority sisters charged with anything? Does John try to sue them for civil damages? Are the seven sisters all named by newspapers? Does the court of public opinion condemn the sisters as rapists?
Tell the truth...or at least don't lie! :)
Flipping the script drives home Pariah's point. If that is your intention.
Does it? Answer my question. Where is the mass outcry for the John Does of the world when they are sexually abused by women in power over them? Who is actually pretending rape isn't a very serious crime that should be pursued without destroying jurisprudence or the reputations (or even lives) of the accused, especially if the accused could be plausibly innocent of some or even all charges?
WHY ARE WE BEING ASKED TO LYNCH THE CORNELL SEVEN BY A FROTHING ANGRY MOB, BOB?!?
And one holds what stock precisely in the braggadocia and ribbing and thrills that follows any orgy involving male virgins and experienced women?
RETWEET!! oh my god yall are a bunch of idiots i’m ashamed to go to the same school as yall
Who are you ashamed of? The ones who wrote the article and take Jane Doe's description from 2024 about what transpired seriously or the ones in the comments who insist that she was raped because she said she was raped and ignore her description of what transpired?
She was not raped by any definition of the word. This scene was one we all (mostly in vain) hoped and strived to at least witness at high school spring break events. If not for the frat President taking measures to prevent such shenanigans in the future due to liability concerns, by barring drunken female party crashers, all involved, of all sexes, would have all emerged wiser and more experienced and confident. As it ever was. (It was the noble woman who hosted the orgies, not the peasantry.)
I’ll be the one to tell you: we don’t take this seriously anymore btw. It’s not a serious position and those with an IQ above about 2 digits are done pretending what you say is anything other than mindless, hate filled drivel
You are a child. This was not a rape, more like a typical High School Spring break weekend in Panama City Florida.
Typical leftist. Throwing a hissy fit tantrum and appealing to emotion instead of presenting a logical argument.
"Half of all women have been sexually assaulted, a statistic purely based on what actually gets reported."
Sources appear to differ on this.
"An estimated 301,580 people ages 12 and up are harmed by sexual violence every year in the U.S., according to the National Crime Victimization Survey."
https://rainn.org/get-informed/sexual-violence-statistics/
Now consider that the US has a population of 340 million, and you get an annual victimization probability on the order of 0.1%
Not sure where this person gets such a statistic, pretty sure that level of sexual assault doesn't even happen with roving gape gangs looking for easy targets!
Ah, yes, lies, damn lies, and damn lying statistics about rape, starting from Mary Koss.
How about you start by defining what you mean by "rape"?
What statistic is fabricated? And when you do your research, you’ll note that the strongest caveat you’ll come across is that sexual assault is one of the most underreported crimes in history. So, take whatever number you find and multiply it.
And I see no “therapy speak” in this cogent and logical comment. Consider just the phrase “free pussy.” That directly implies that normally, pussy has a cost to it, and here’s some that you can get without paying anything. You don’t see what’s so terribly bad about the mind that would post that phrase on social media?
The only underreporting of sexual assault _I_ see from where I'm sitting is the underreporting of sexual assault by women, of men.
And if pussy didn't cost something, then why are the men being sued in civil court for damages? What was damaged?
I think you're trolling, because that reply is way too on-the-nose.
But that is true. Normally, men can't have sex with women for "free." That's just reality. Women generally expect to be paid in terms of love, affection, or at least erotic pleasure. Here, the woman didn't demand much of anything.
Thank you for proving my point. You see sex as something that men “get” from women, not something that men and women equally share. You see sex as payment for something you give to a woman. Perhaps you wouldn’t give things like love and affection to women unless they first give you sex, raising the question of what those words actually mean to you.
Perhaps you say that because it’s been your experience — no woman has ever wanted to have sex with you because she wanted to, without receiving something in return. Or, perhaps that’s just the way you see women, and sex, and the world.
RAINN estimates ~300K victims annually in the US which would imply an annual victimization probability of around 0.1%
https://rainn.org/get-informed/sexual-violence-statistics/
As for the "free pussy" comment, feminists claim that rape is supposedly usually about power, not "pussy". So the comment would appear to suggest the individual involved is *not* a rapist according to feminist dogma at least.
The issue is more with humanity adapting to the phenomenon of social media rather than with the phrase .. which to me is entirely apropos and banal for the demographic expressing it. It is just that until now, shuck and jive in the moment was not published in stone to the planet and for eternity.
this is so gross and tone deaf
I'm here just to call out comments that shit on this article without actually engaging with any of the article's arguments! Come on, if you take issue with the article then surely you can muster up some actual reasons ...
ah and the harmonious society of "she was raped, get the rapists" is the kind of society you want to live in, Regina? :)
Typical leftist. Throwing a hissy fit tantrum and appealing to emotion instead of presenting a logical argument.
It's one thing for an article to evoke negative response to the substance of the article. The author is free to speak - and the readers are free to speak in disagreement - absolutely. But what is troubling to me as a 53 year old woman, feminist, leftist, attorney - is when people go beyond panning an article - or vigorously disputing its substance - to wanting/ demanding/ feeling entitled to "consequences" for the author, and even the publisher! This punitive, reactionary, proverbial *pearl clutching* zeitgeist - is anathema to the "marketplace of ideas," a cornerstone of American political philosophy. True- the First Amendment only applies to government actors. But the philosophical tenet on which it rests is broadly applicable, and Americans typically agree in the abstract that we benefit as a society from a free marketplace of ideas. So why the knee jerk inclination to get heads on stakes.
To quote John Stuart Mill for the Columbia core curriculum crowd - "[T]he peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error." In short: attack the speech not the speaker (and certainly not the publisher).
Also, some of the article was lazy and I think a bit tone deaf failing to recognize how triggered women are by this and reflecting more seriously about why that is (If it's hysterical; it's historical.) But the issues are not black and white in that case. My friend and criminal defense attorney Tiffany Blacknell (@lwyrchc) is covering this case going over the charges against each of the 7 guys - because it is not fair to lump them all together. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DecbfxzvkNF/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! I really appreciate your perspective as someone outside of the Columbia “bubble.” I hope we can all learn and build off of each other and respectfully, intelligently, disagree!
Thanks, everyone involved with the article and subsequent discussion is well advised to listen and learn from the opposing viewpoints, but as a mother and fully grown adult, I beseech everyone to take any *lessons learned* in stride. No one should be attacked as a *person* for writing or publishing or defending an article. You digital native Gen Zers have a harder life than Gen X ever did (don't believe the internet hype). Protect your mental health, dears/ : )
'"doing anything more" than walking into the room, doing ketamine, and leaving.' Meaning he was a witness and did not report or do anything to stop it -- and entered the room after receiving the message.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/03/nyregion/cornell-men-university-discipline.html
Since Cornell did not do enough to punish these criminals, there are social measures in place. Being plastered all over the internet is a social repercussion for rape, assault, and bystanding these crimes -- and a mild one compared to civil or criminal trials. And it is a (hopefully) successful discouragement and cautionary measure for future potential offenders.
but you are ignoring her agency. i will retract if the facts are different than i understand them, i'm not professing to have them all, which is precisely why I have not passed full judgment. It sounds wild to me but the woman was agreeing and consenting to much of what sounds wild to me, right? Are you suggesting that someone who walks into a room, sees all this sees a woman seemingly freely doing ketamine and engaging in sexual activities is obligated now to report htat woman because she couldn't possibly be exercising free will. I think this is the point the article was touching upon, even if clumsily and too cavalierly. (is that a word? lol)
Does he have some duty to report fornication that the woman had supposedly agreed to? Was there criminal rape going on in that room? What if these men were black, or muslim, or homosexual, or transwomen? :)
There was at least one Moslem and one black among the 7
Uh oh, that’s two ‘tisms from Ms. Jane Doe, according to the oppression olympics, unless the moslem and black having penises cancels the oppression of religion and race out? I’m not smart enough to play that game, alas…
Who elected you to determine when a crime has occurred and to “punish these criminals”?
I cannot stop you from sticking your fingers in your ears and covering your eyes to the damning evidence; the recorded phone calls and the groupchat.
> at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don't think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,
― Lucy Craig, a.k.a. "Jane Doe"
the recorded phone calls and the groupchat is proof of vulgar crassness, try again mr. white knight, you're not impressing any princesses very much.
My question stands.
If you are referring to Scott K., he was absolved by the university of doing Ketamine off of Jane Doe. She did not allege in her statement that she saw him do it and admitted she did not see him do this. He produced a negative drug test for Ketamine.
Of course, while Jane Doe says he and the other Scott were asking if she was okay neither called an Uber to get her home.
Beyond the (numerous) ways in which this piece is morally repugnant in its seemingly either ignorant or shameless reliance on basic rape culture rhetoric, this is also just...really bad journalism? The facts of the case mentioned are neither comprehensive nor up to date
Typical leftist. Throwing a hissy fit tantrum and appealing to emotion instead of presenting a logical argument.
> at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don't think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,
― Lucy Craig, a.k.a. "Jane Doe"
Yep, I'm waiting. I just want to call out comments that shit on this article without actually engaging with any of the article's arguments! Come on, if you take issue with the article then surely you can muster up some actual reasons ...
so rich to assert that the public is infantilizing Jane Doe by treating her account of her own assault as true…when you undermine her ability to understand the reality of the brutal violence she experienced and attempt to write it off as her simply rejecting her own ability to make “bad decisions”. it is not infantilizing to say that women are being assaulted and it’s honestly disgusting that you think so. this is not “good faith discourse”
Which Jane Doe am I supposed to believe, Jane Doe before the sex, Jane Doe before campus police, or Jane Doe after apparently some internet chatroom convinced her she was totally raped?
Jane Doe’s story has been consistent and is believable. While her interpretation of what happened has changed and she is drawing different conclusions the underlying facts are essentially the same.
so what are the facts of the case as we have them, because i keep getting two different versions: "Jane Doe, Girl Gone Wild" versus "Jane Doe, Lifetime Movie of the Week"
The reason there appears to be inconsistencies between her statement to police and her civil Complaint is due to the fact that the Complaint is written in conclusory language. In other words, because it alleged that Jane Doe had consumed enough alcohol to be unable legally to provide consent (even if, subjectively, at the time she may not have considered herself to be that drunk). So her evidence states that she was “5 or 6 out of 10” drunk and agreed to a threesome she was "excited" about, which then occurred. The civil Complaint states: "In her drunken state, Plaintiff was incapable of consenting" and that sex was "forced" upon her.
That sounds very different! But if you strip away the conclusory language they are in agreement with the underlying facts: she was drunk, she agreed to a threesome, the threesome occured. The difference is that her subjective opinion at the time as that she was 5-6/10 drunk and the civil Complaint asserts that that level of intoxication (based on 12+ drinks in a short amount of time as well as, potentially Ketamine), as a legal matter, means that any consent must be vitiated. You do not need to agree with her lawyers' legal theory to believe her evidence.
The only inconsistencies that I could find are minor and appear to be errors by her lawyer (e.g. she was a sophomore, not a junior and one of the defendants left the room, which is not noted in her civil Complaint).
> Jane Doe’s story has been consistent and is believable.
"at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don't think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,"
― Lucy Craig, a.k.a. "Jane Doe"
Yes that is what I said, her interpretation of what happened has changed but the underlying facts are the same. She noted she was "excited" about the first threesome and agreed to it (i.e. the threesome she is texting Newell about).
Typical leftist. Throwing a hissy fit tantrum and appealing to emotion instead of presenting a logical argument.
As a longtime card-carrying , 90s-women’s-college feminist I support having this conversation. Nothing should be off limits, and Paglia’s perspective has long been debated in the feminist canon. Please don’t freak out about an article in a free speech publication, off all things, now.✌️
I used to be a second-wave egalitarian, until I took the black pill suppository of "nobody actually gave a fuck about equality except for us mooks, it was about using us for power, socialism where women are the proletariat, a utopia where the bottom 90% of men are all liquidated, victimhood grievance narratives forever" :(
This would be a fitting article for a free speech paper, yes. Sundial was founded to be pro-dialogue. A magazine cannot be both.
Interesting distinction.
Makes me proud to be a Barnard grad. Beautifully written. I know you both are coming from a place of compassion. In college, the desire to break through boundaries can be so strong.
Thank you so much! This means the world.
I am an in my 50s, an attorney, a feminist, a career woman in a field dominated by men who has had to fight when necessary for equal treatment and against discrimination. And I am very relieved to see that you have said what so many are thinking. Couldn't have said it better myself. I want you to know how much publishing this article is appreciated by many.
Thank you for sharing your perspective! I hope more people understand that our opinion really isn’t extreme “rage-bait,” and that many people share it too!
Incredible and poignant article. Not sure how one can rebut (besides highly emotional, despondent women)
You all AS A WHOLE should be ASHAMED of yourselves. Incredibly out of touch, gross of you all to belittle victim's traumatic experiences.
I'm here just to call out comments that shit on this article without actually engaging with any of the article's arguments! Come on, if you take issue with the article then surely you can muster up some actual reasons ...
She's not the vic, she's the perp.
Which victim? You want us to lynch some allegeds again? What for?
Typical leftist. Throwing a hissy fit tantrum and appealing to emotion instead of presenting a logical argument.
Some similar themes explored here: https://freebeacon.com/campus/cornells-president-misses-the-point-in-a-telling-way/
This is one of the best articles I have read about this incident and the entire social problematic. Thank you for writing it.
It is astonishing how much can be written about a subject without making any true progress or original contribution in the debate. This piece, I think, is the rare example of an honest attempt to tackle the issue beyond the usual performative listing of talking points. We need much more of that. Especially because the typical article (and many of the response articles I have seen) can probably be better written by AI these days.
Thank you for this and I hope to hear more from you.
Thank you so much Andreas, this means so much to us. We will never stop writing and fighting for intellectual diversity in civil discourse!
Well done. This piece challenges the mob mentality that has dominated this story from the beginning. My core values steer me towards supporting and believing women when they say they have been victimized, but, I would ask the question: are all women telling the truth about these things every single time? Is it disgraceful to simply analyze the event on its own merit and allow for a dissenting view? When I was in college, I went to a bar and ended up having drinks with a girl that I had met before but didn't really know that well. Unknown to me that night was that she had a big crush on one of my close friends. We got drunk and she lavished me with public displays of affection that was noticed by all in our group. She came back to my apartment with me and we had sex (used her condom). At no point were either of us so drunk that we could not give consent. She left that night and shortly afterwards starts telling people that I had raped her. She had men in our town trying to hunt me down. Turns out, she just didn't want my friend, who she liked, to know that she had willingly had sex with me because she thought it would ruin her chances with him. In the end, when things started getting out of hand, she confessed that she made the story up. So, from my experience, the whole "all women should be believed all of the time" is met with a certain degree of skepticism because I know that women, like men, sometimes lie. This does not mean that I never believe women when they say they are abused; I just think that the possibility exists that stories can be fabricated when there are motivations for doing so.
Hallelujah. Sanity. Best thing I’ve read about this Cornell story.
Thank you so much!
Thank you!! I’ve been waiting to read your peace on this and then a friend just sent it to me this morning. Such clear and intelligent thinking.
Piece