Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Martin Bollis's avatar

I think this is a very mature post, thank you. I hope people on both sides take note, but doubt it.

I was recently involved in a (civil) exchange on Substack. I made the point that open borders mean an unlimited labour pool, which has to be bad for the working class. Voting against it from a working class perspective is rational rather than racist. I was told that’s just flat wrong. They’ve somehow been convinced of it against the evidence.

I had an exchange on Medium a while back. It was civil until the lady said 25% of women serving in the armed forces have been raped. It seemed such an astonishing allegation that I fact checked it. I replied (with links) that 25% of females in the armed forces have complained about some level of harassment, ranging from off colour remarks to pinched bottoms, but only a tiny proportion have alleged rape, of which a smaller percentage were prosecuted. I got a “calling me a liar” diatribe and the conversation.

ended abruptly.

I fear tribal allegiances are strongly held and difficult to budge.

Expand full comment
Maureen Kelly's avatar

Great job!

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts